A federal judge has dismissed a lawsuit filed by a Springfield ICE observer against seven unnamed ICE agents.
According to District Judge Michael Newman, the court lacks jurisdiction because six of the officers have left Springfield, and there’s no evidence of ongoing harassment.
The plaintiff is Sean Moorman. He alleges the ICE agents were systematically harassing him because he was publicly monitoring their activities.
Moorman and his ACLU attorney contend one ICE agent remains in the city, and the others can return at any time. But the judged ruled with only one agent remaining, the chance Moorman will encounter him specifically is "reasonably low.”
The judge had issued a temporary restraining order against the ICE agents until Oct. 2, directing them to cease any further “threatening, intimidating and retaliatory action.”
However, the judge declined to convert it into a preliminary injunction and dismissed the case.
David Carey, managing legal director at ACLU of Ohio, said the court held that peaceful observers have a First Amendment right to document, photograph, and record federal officers, and that the seven ICE officers in question likely violated that right.
"But ultimately, when confronted by the ACLU, the government chose to conceal and protect the wrongdoers rather than face accountability in court," Carey stated. "It withheld their identities and then moved them around in a shell game, redeploying 6 of them away from Springfield after the lawsuit was filed."