Franklin County Judge Julie Lynch placed retired Columbus police officer Ricky Anderson on three years' probation for the shooting death of 20-year-old Donovan Lewis.
"Your honor, I do apologize to each and every one of Donovan's family," Anderson told Lynch. "I'm sorry to my family for what they've had to go through for the last four years. This has been a very trying time. I've suffered a lot. Everybody's suffered a lot."
Anderson shot Lewis, a Black man, in 2022 while helping serve an overnight warrant for Lewis' arrest in Columbus' Hilltop neighborhood.
Anderson was a Columbus police dog handler at the time. Body camera footage showed him shooting Lewis in his bed a moment after a door was opened and Lewis woke up.
Anderson said he believed that Lewis had a gun. It turned out that Lewis had a vape pen in his hand.
Anderson pleaded guilty to reckless homicide in September with an Alford plea, which acknowledged that there was enough evidence to support a conviction without Anderson actually admitting guilt.
Prosecutors dropped a murder charge.
Before Anderson's sentencing Wednesday in Franklin County Court of Common Pleas, several members of Lewis' family spoke.
Lewis' mother, Rebecca Duran, told Lynch that she wakes up every night around 2 or 3 a.m. — roughly the time that Lewis was killed.
"I say a prayer to Donovan and try to go back to sleep," Duran said.
Duran said the hardest days are when Lewis' son, who was born after his death, asks why he can't see his dad.
Duran, like other members of Lewis' family, asked Lynch to sentence Anderson to three years in prison, the maximum possible sentence given his plea.
"I ask that you please make him accountable today. Donovan deserves better. We all deserve to have them in our life," Duran said through tears.
When Lynch announced that Anderson would instead receive three years of community control, better known as probation, Duran let out a cry and slumped on the gallery bench with her head in her arms.
Lynch said that Anderson had killed Lewis by mistake and that "it wasn't purposeful, it wasn't intentional, and it wasn't homicide."
"The problem is what the family wants really is vengeance. And we're here for justice," Lynch said.
She said the family accepted Anderson's plea and they should have understood that it came with no presumption of prison time.
Lewis' family and friends swore as they left the courtroom. One woman muttered, "You let him get away with murder."
Another woman said, "They always do."
After the sentencing, Anderson's attorney, Mark Collins, told media that Anderson had been hesitant to plead even to lesser charges in the case because Lewis' death was a "mistake."
"He did this so that the Lewis family could in fact take a step towards another step in the grieving process," Collins said.
Anderson's other attorney, Kaitlyn Stephens, said that probation will put restrictions on Anderson. That could include mental health assessments, restrictions on travel or required counseling. Anderson is not allowed to own a gun.
Lynch said that if Anderson violates the terms of his probation, he will go to prison for three years.
Robert Gresham, an attorney for Lewis' family, said that the family respects the court and the legal process but that they were unhappy with the sentencing.
"When we talk about justice, justice has to apply to officers just as much as it applies to the people being policed. We're disappointed in the outcome here," Gresham said.
Gresham said that Anderson's Alford plea means he can't contest that he was reckless in civil cases.
The family's civil case against Anderson is expected to go to trial in February.